University of Washington Researchers Analyze Effects of Powder Reuse on 3D printed Metal Parts

Researchers from the University of Washington are exploring further complexities of material science in metal printing, outlining their findings in the recently published ‘Electron beam additive manufacturing of Ti6A14V: Evolution of powder morphology and part microstructure with powder reuse.’

Concerned with quality for aerospace applications, the authors designed this study to address ‘fundamental issues’ concerning the use of powder bed fusion in additive manufacturing—mainly in re-use. As additive manufacturing continues to increase in popularity for industrial users, the benefits become more apparent—from the ability to create complex and optimized geometries to using significantly fewer materials that are stronger and more durable, yet light in weight. As is generally the case though, challenges exist, such as slow processing times.

“The opportunities for metal AM to be used for manufacturing components with stress-critical applications has caused need for greater understanding of the process,” state the authors.

During the process of EBM powder bed fusion, the characteristics and quality of powder are critical as it is sequentially deposited, sintered, and melted. There are the obvious benefits of reusing powder to cut down on waste of materials, but the effects on mechanical properties of parts are of concern—and an area that the authors point out has previously not been researched fully—and when it has, reuse cycles have involved ‘relatively low exposure time of the powder during the build process.’

“There are many concerns that remain to be addressed in powder reuse for metal AM,” state the researchers, pointing out the necessity for an analysis of part microstructure.

Researching powder reuse in EBM AM of Ti6Al4V, the authors performed 30 build cycles. They also investigated the following:

  • Transformations in powder chemistry
  • Particle size distribution with reuse
  • Effects on the built metal part

“The novelty of this investigation regarding powder reuse is in the large number of reuse cycles achieved for EBM AM, the extensive evaluation of powder that was performed, and the complimentary evaluation of the part microstructure,” stated the authors.

Details of the manufactured specimens. (a) Schematic diagram of the parts and their distribution in each build. Parts in each build include (A) six vertical and (B) six horizontal oriented flat tensile specimen (ASTM E08M), a (C) vertical and horizontal oriented staircase, a (D) small cylinder, and (E) a cylindrical step pyramid. (b) geometry of the staircase specimens and (c) pyramid specimen showing relevant dimensions and locations of repeated microstructural analysis as highlighted by the squares.

Grade 5 Titanium alloy (Ti6Al4V) was used, with the 30 builds performed over six months on an ARCAM A2X Electron Beam AM system, from ‘b1 for the first build performed with 50 kg of virgin powder and subsequently up to b30 for the final build.’

Micrograph of the “as-built” microstructure. (a) prior β grains with boundaries outlined with red arrows. (b) The line intercept method employed to determine the prior β grain columnar width. (c) Micrograph of as-built microstructure with highlighted β ribs and α laths.

During the study and ongoing builds, the research team noted that particles did change in size, and both surface texture and morphology changed also as the powder was reused.

Progression of powder size and morphology through the reuse process. (a) In virgin powder (b1), particle surfaces are relatively smooth and they have high sphericity. There is numerous tiny particles that agglomerate or adhere to the surface of larger particles. Representative views of powder in b7, b10, and b20 in (b)–(d), respectively, show the progression of particle surface damage and the absence of tiny particles. In b30 (e), the particles are irregular with some exhibiting major deformation and damage.

Examples of damaged particles in powder of b1, b14, and b30. Specimen examples of (a) fractured, (b) agglomerated/fused, and (c) melted/irregular particles are shown, respectively. In general, damaged particle of these types were found in the powder of all builds evaluated by SEM.

Staircase and pyramid part samples were used in this study to examine how powder reuse affected the printed Ti6Al4V microstructure. Both samples were cross-sectioned and mounted during evaluation, polished, then etched by immersion.

“In comparing responses for the two geometries, the primary difference in microstructure between the pyramids and staircases is the broader spread of alpha volume and lath thickness in the pyramid, along with the increase in alpha lath thickness with powder reuse,” stated the researchers in discussion.

Prior β grain dimensions for the pyramid (a) and staircase (b).

“One of the most marked changes in powder with reuse was the increase in surface deformation to the particles and physical damage. The particles changed shape with reuse cycles from spherical geometry to increasingly deformed with surface dimples and irregular shape,” concluded the researchers. “This aspect of the powder degradation appears to result from the mechanical aspects of the recycling and part extraction process. In addition, there was an increase in fractured particles, partially fused particles and recast particles with powder reuse.”

[Source / Images – ‘Electron beam additive manufacturing of Ti6A14V: Evolution of powder morphology and part microstructure with powder reuse’]

The post University of Washington Researchers Analyze Effects of Powder Reuse on 3D printed Metal Parts appeared first on 3DPrint.com | The Voice of 3D Printing / Additive Manufacturing.

Ti6Al4V in Selective Laser Melting: Analysis of Laser Polishing Techniques

Chinese researchers are expanding on new materials and technology for improving surface quality in metal 3D printing, outlining their findings in ‘Laser Polishing of Ti6Al4V Fabricated by Selective Laser Melting.’ SLM technology allows for fabrication of complex parts and is becoming increasingly more popular due to the latitude allowed for designers and researchers, as well as greater efficiency in production.

In this study, the researchers focus on the positive benefits for bioprinting, and the versatility offered for fabrication of implants related to bone fusion. Inferior surface finish is one of the greatest challenges, however, resulting in the following issues:

  • Stair-step effect
  • Low-dimensional precision
  • Increased friction
  • Low therapeutic effect

“Various conventional post-processing treatments, such as sandblasting, chemical polishing, electrolytic polishing, machining, ultrasonic polishing, and oxidation have been used on metallic AM (Additive Manufacturing) components to reduce their surface roughness. However, several drawbacks, such as being time-consuming, it is difficult to obtain machine precision components, chemical risks, and low efficiency, limit the clinical application and development of these treatments,” explain the authors.

Laser polishing can solve some of these problems, working with smaller, complex parts that require accuracy, and offers the capability of high-speed polishing at lower cost. Laser polishing also refines mechanical properties, offering improvement which is of ongoing interest to users around the world whether in experimenting with composites, color, 4D materials, or more.

“A comprehensive analysis of the roughness, porosity, fatigue behavior, and biocompatibility, along with the relationships between them, of components after LP should be conducted prior to applying LP technology to implantable medical devices,” explained the researchers regarding the motivation for their study, as they worked to improve on surface roughness and resulting finish.

“The findings of this study can play a guiding role in other processes that involve biomedical materials,” said the researchers.

All samples, created with Ti6Al4V alloy, were polished in a rectangular cavity with argon, used to decrease the possibility of oxidation on parts.

(a) Test specimens; (b) a schematic view of the laser polishing (LP).

During analysis, samples displayed metallic ‘globules,’ which the researchers noted were ‘only loosely bonded during additive manufacturing processes. Small particles and microcracks persisted, however, displayed on the LP-1 sample, while the LP-2 sample was polished with no defects. For sample LP-3 there was concern over reconstructed islands and cracks.

Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of the (a) as-received sample, the (b) LP-1 sample, the (c) LP-2 sample, and the (d) LP-3 sample.

Laser scanning confocal microscope (LSCM) images of the (a) as-received sample, the (b) LP-1 sample, the (c) LP-2 sample, and (d) the LP-3 sample.

While laser treatments caused changes that affected wettability, the authors note that some previous research has shown a positive connection related to surface topography. In evaluating pore distribution, samples were analyzed as the researchers sliced then from a variety of lengths from the surface. All samples displayed mechanical properties that were similar, in terms of tensile and yield strength and elongation. With the exception of the high-cycle fatigue test, fatigue behavior was almost the same in all samples.

The pore distribution of the as-received sample at different distances: (a) 0–10 μm; (b) 30–40 μm; (c) 60–70 μm, and (d) 70–100 μm. The pore distribution of the LP-2 sample at different distances: (e) 0–10 μm; (f) 30–40 μm; (g) 60–70 μm; and (h) 70–100 μm. (The purple part of the image, after threshold segmentation, is the pore.)

Mechanical properties: (a) microhardness distributions in the laser-polished layer, (b) tensile properties, (c) stress–life fatigue behavior for all geometries showing combined data points, and (d) stress life fatigue curves.

“The cell experiment showed that the LP-2 parameters improved cell adhesion and exhibited cell proliferation. The results indicate that LP improved the cell biocompatibility, while hydrophilicity positively affected early cell adhesion,” concluded the researchers.

What do you think of this news? Let us know your thoughts! Join the discussion of this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com.

Adhesion and proliferation of MC3T3-E1 cells grown on different sample surfaces. (a) The as-received sample, (b) the LP-1 sample, (c) the LP-2 sample, and the (d) LP-3 sample. In images a–d: F-actin cytoskeleton of osteoblasts (red) and cell nuclei (blue) after 1 day of seeding.

[Source / Images: ‘Laser Polishing of Ti6Al4V Fabricated by Selective Laser Melting’]

The post Ti6Al4V in Selective Laser Melting: Analysis of Laser Polishing Techniques appeared first on 3DPrint.com | The Voice of 3D Printing / Additive Manufacturing.

Additive Manufacturing: Still a Real Need for Design Guidelines in Electron Beam Melting

Researchers from King Saud University in Saudi Arabia explore the potential—and the challenges—for industrial users engaged in metal 3D printing via EBM processes. Their findings are outlined in the recently published ‘Design for Metal Additive Manufacturing – An Investigation of Key Design Application on Electron Beam Melting,’ as authors Wadea Ameen, Abdulrahman Al-Ahmari, and Osama Abdulhameed not only explore metal 3D printing but work to establish more specific guidelines for designers and engineers.

Electron beam melting (EBM) is an additive manufacturing technique used in many critical applications today like the production of aviation and aerospace components, medical implants and devices, further development of materials, and more. The authors point out however that a lack of Design for Additive Manufacturing (DFAM) rules continues to cause challenge in using certain AM technologies.

Defined as a method that ‘considers the functional performance and other product considerations like manufacturability, reliability, and cost,’ DFAM is a system that helps designers choose parameters and create successful prototypes and necessary high-performance parts with less error.

While considerable research has been performed in assessing mechanical properties and improving methods, not so much attention has yet been given to design rules for EBM.

Following are procedures the researchers recommend guidelines for:

  • Benchmark parts – designed and 3D printed to offer a better way to test small features and overhang structures.
  • Minimum Resolvable Feature Size – assesses feasibility for production of wall thicknesses, slots, holes, and more.
  • Overhang structures – support structure limits should be added, considering three fundamentals: angle overhang with varying angles, convex overhang with varying radius, and hole overhang with varying diameters
  • Materials and equipment – for this study, Ti6Al4V in powder form with particles size of 30-50 µm was used, with an ARCAM A2 3D printer.

Features configurations (a) round holes (b) walls thickness (c) round bars (d) round slots (e) cubed slots

Overhang structures (a) angle overhang (b) convex overhang (c) round hole overhang

“In general, the results showed that the minimum though round hole is 0.5 mm diameter, the minimum wall thickness, minimum round bar, minimum round slot and minimum cubed slot that can produced by EBM are 0.6 mm, 0.65 mm, 0.1 mm and 0.4 mm, respectively. Also, the results showed the lowest self-supporting angle overhang is 50 degrees, the smallest radius of self-supporting convex curve overhang is 7 mm radius, and the smallest self-supporting hole is 18 mm diameter,” concluded the researchers.

“The change of the material builds orientation, and the process parameters will result in change of the manufacturability limitations. For future work, other features could be considered and the effect of features orientation as well as the process parameters could be investigated.”

Small fabricated holes

What do you think of this news? Let us know your thoughts! Join the discussion of this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com.

Fabricated overhang test specimens by EBM

[Source / Images: ‘Design for Metal Additive Manufacturing – An Investigation of Key Design Application on Electron Beam Melting’]

The post Additive Manufacturing: Still a Real Need for Design Guidelines in Electron Beam Melting appeared first on 3DPrint.com | The Voice of 3D Printing / Additive Manufacturing.

nScrpyt uses microdispensing to develop metal 3D printing solution

Florida-based 3D printer and microdispensing system manufacturer nScrypt Inc. has announced it is developing a metal 3D printing solution to provide its customers with detailed and repeatable metal parts. Using its microdispensing technology, nScrypt is aiming to specifically provide the metal parts to the aerospace, defense, and medical industries. 3D printing high-strength and high-density titanium […]